Why this matters
The confusion between “window guards” and “window security bars” is a real problem: parents sometimes buy a security bar thinking it will protect their child from falls, not realizing the products have different engineering requirements. This guide clarifies both, and is upfront that SWB bars are security bars, not child window guards.
The terms look interchangeable in a Google search. They're not. One is engineered to resist outward pressure from a child's body weight. The other resists inward force from a forced entry attempt. If you need both, use a product made and tested for each job.
Quick answer
Window guards vs. window security bars: window guards are designed to prevent children from falling out of windows: they resist outward pressure and require an adult-operable quick release. Security bars are designed to slow down unauthorized entry: they resist exterior force and, on bedroom escape windows, must release from inside (IRC R310.4.4 / IBC § 1031.6). The products look similar but serve different primary functions. SWB bars are security bars, not certified window guards, and should not be relied on to prevent child falls. On bedroom windows, SWB Model A/EXIT adds an inside quick release (designed to meet IRC R310.4.4 / IBC § 1031.6; verify with your local building department).
What the law actually requires
Window guard requirements vary dramatically by jurisdiction. New York City has one of the best-known rules: under NYC Health Code §131.15, landlords of multiple dwellings must install window guards in apartments where a child 10 or younger lives, or when a tenant asks. Only guards approved by the NYC Department of Health and Mental Hygiene qualify, and windows to fire escapes are exempt. SWB bars are not NYC-approved window guards.
Outside NYC, most states and municipalities have no window guard mandate. The model building codes (IRC/IBC) address egress for security bars and set minimum sill heights or window opening control devices for some new construction, but they don't require guards in existing homes. For fall prevention, look for guards or window opening control devices tested to ASTM F2090.
For homeowners (rather than landlords), the decision is usually voluntary, so match the product to the job. A child safety guard is not engineered to stop a forced entry. A security bar is not tested to stop a child from falling, and one without an inside quick release could trap a child in a room during a fire. If you need both protections, plan for both products.
See our full burglar bars guide for security-specific product selection, and our installation guide for egress considerations during install.
Same look, different purpose
Window guards
Primarily designed to prevent children from falling out of windows. Tested to withstand pressure from the inside (a child leaning or pushing against them), typically to ASTM F2090 or a local approval; models for escape windows include an adult-operable release.
Window security bars
Designed to slow down unauthorized entry from outside. Built to resist exterior force; bars on bedroom escape windows must release from inside so occupants can get out.
The products look similar, but the engineering priorities are different. In common usage, the terms are often used interchangeably, which creates confusion.
Choose the right product
Window Guards
- Children under 10 in household
- Upper-floor windows (2nd+ floor)
- NYC mandatory requirements
- Child fall prevention primary concern
Security Bars
- Ground floor burglary prevention
- Any floor security concern
- Accessible windows
- Bedrooms: a model with inside quick release (e.g., A/EXIT)
Feature comparison
| Feature | Window guard | Security bar |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Purpose | Prevent child falls | Prevent unauthorized entry |
| Force Direction | Inside-out resistance | Outside-in resistance |
| Quick-Release | Some models include an adult-operable release | Required on bedroom escape windows (IRC R310.4.4 / IBC § 1031.6) |
| Tested To | ASTM F2090 or local approval (e.g., NYC) | Varies by maker — check specs |
| NYC Window Guard Law | Health Dept.–approved guards required | Not a window guard — does not satisfy it |
What SWB bars are, and aren't
SWB bars are built for one job: making windows harder to get through from outside. On bedroom windows, Model A/EXIT adds an inside quick release (lift the end tube and the module swings open like a door, no keys or tools) and is designed to meet IRC R310.4.4 / IBC § 1031.6 (verify with your local building department). Models A and B have no quick release and belong on non-sleeping rooms.
Important: SWB bars are security products, not child safety window guards. They are not tested to ASTM F2090, are not NYC-approved, and should not be relied on to prevent falls. If you need fall prevention, use a certified window guard or window opening control device.
About this guide: general information, not legal advice. Code references name the model code section (IBC, IRC) so you can look it up yourself. Codes are adopted and amended locally; final requirements are set by your local authority having jurisdiction (AHJ).
Window guards FAQ
Are window guards required by law?
In some jurisdictions, yes. New York City requires landlords to install approved window guards in apartments where a child 10 or younger lives, or when a tenant requests them. Most other places have no general mandate — check with your local health or building department.
Do window guards stop burglars?
Child safety window guards are designed to prevent falls, not break-ins. Security bars are designed to slow down entry, not to prevent falls. If you need both, use a certified window guard for fall prevention and a security bar for intrusion — and remember that bars over a bedroom escape window must release from inside.
What is the difference between a window guard and a window security bar?
Window guards are designed primarily to prevent children from falling out of windows. Security bars are designed to prevent unauthorized entry. The terms overlap in common usage, but the products serve different functions and are tested differently. SWB makes security bars, not certified window guards.
Questions about your windows?
Send the width and height of each window and the wall type, and we'll reply by email.